Thursday, June 04, 2009

Glos go down again

T20: Warwickshire 139-6 beat Gloucestershire 135-7 by four wickets

Gloucestershire slumped to a fifth Twenty20 defeat at Edgbaston, and with it their chances of getting out the group all but disappeared.

The disastrous dismissal (again) of Hamish Marshall as he was run out by the bowler having played the ball back up the pitch, set the tone in a scrappy innings where the Shire could only post 135, and despite chipping away at the Warwickshire batsman, the target was never going to be demanding enough. So what has gone wrong once again in the 20-over format?

Well clearly the loss of James Franklin as been a key factor. The loss of the all-rounder has created a serious imbalance in the side. Franklin had been performing steadily with the ball, but crucially had found some form with the bat; innings in several Friends Provident games saw Franklin begin to justify his recruitment. But his replacement in the side has gone to a genuine bowler, that has left Glos with a horrifically long tail.

Admittedly, I favoured the decision to play just five batsman - all players of quality, and players that should be backed. However, one-day cricket often works best with plenty of bits-and-pieces cricketers: the Paul Collingwood's and Dimi Mascarenas' of this world. So perhaps Rob Woodman or David Brown warranted inclusion as a like-for-like replacement for Franklin?

Granted, the side have not batted well at all, but surely bolstering the batting would be no more a shot for the confidence of the top order, but a sensible insurance policy to avoid what has been described as "an end being opened": the removal of enough recognised batsman to bring in the lesser players to place more pressure on the player at the other end - a trick that has brought the downfall of the Shire so far in this competition.

Unless runs are on the board, a team has no chance of victory - so a gamble on small numbers to get those runs cannot continue. Albeit unlucky with Franklin and Will Porterfield's international duty, players that are genuinely recognised to bat have to be introduced because not enough runs are being scored.

All-rounders are capable of producing cricket that can work in one-day cricket, so why not get both Woodman and Brown in the side, in place of the one-dimensional cricketers that have not been doing their jobs and have seen the Shire slump out of the Twenty20 cup.


  1. Was yet another fairly close game. I thought a miracle was on at 4 down. That Dawson over that went for 12 just when a little bit of pressure was building, was key I think.

    Now we are out, Brown or Woodman should get a runout I think.

  2. David Brown has been a solid performer in the limited over game for us, but he was cast aside this year in favour of the 5 specialist bowlers approach - which has not worked!!!
    Get him back in the side (and Woodman) and the T20 side looks much better balanced. Only one spinner should be played - and that should be Banerjee - Dawson is looking past it at the mo.

  3. I agree we need Brown in, but I don't think that Woodman's ready, very little experience. You would have thought that if they were going to drop Taylor they would put in someone like Snell (fantastic batsman) or indeed Brown, perhaps if they drop Dawson and re-drop Kadeer and bring in both Brown and Snell we might have a chance of getting some points.

    We get so close every match and then 'snatch defeat out of the jaws of victory', it's that killer instinct we're lacking.

    Guess what...Hamish Marshall got out unnecessarily again, he's got such potential but wastes it every match!

    Hodnett's been looking good, and I hope he starts tomorrow.

  4. Just seen confirmation that Hodnett's in the squad going to Chesterfield

  5. the non selection of Brown has had me non plussed as he has performed well in the past in one day formats and especially 20/20. The Glos management do not seem to like to admit they are wrong and have ploughed on with their misguided 5 batter policy and this has cost us.

    I also think that Hardinges' contribution to Glos one day side over the last few years has been underestimated as on more than one occasion he put bat to ball in the late overs of the game

  6. I thought that David Vrown was injured??


Please click the above advertisment - it will generate revenue for Glos Cricket Radio.


CLICK HERE for the latest Gloucestershire Cricket updates.
The views expressed on this website are those of the author and not necessarily those of Gloucestershire County Cricket Club.